R.C.C. | Pre-stressed |
30% to 40% of total cross-sectional area is utilized | Hundred percent cross-sectional area is utilized |
Section is an economical beyond spans of 10m to 12m (load heavy) | Economical up to spans of 25 to 30 m (load small) |
Self weight of section is higher | Self weight of section is lesser |
Cracking and corrosion problems are more | No cracking and corrosion problems |
Reinforcement is straight | Reinforcing tendons can be bent or have parabolic shapes |
Tension is developed below neutral axis | The whole cross section is in compression |
Stresses are developed only after external load is allowed | Stresses are developed before counting due to pre compressive load |
Generally large in size and require additional share reinforcement to resist shear forces | In P.C. section are smaller in size and due to pre stressed tendon a considerable amount of shear reinforcement is avoided |
It does not require any auxiliary units much for construction | Auxiliary units are required live anchoring devices, equipments for prestressing |
SR.No. | Pre-Tensioning | Post-Tensioning |
1. | Tendons are tensional before costing the concrete. | Tendons are tensioned after the concrete has fully hardened |
2. | One end of tensioned is secured an abutment and another is pulled by using jack then concrete is poured. After hardening the concrete the ends of tendon are released prestress is transmitted to the concrete by action of bond between the reinforcement and surrounding concrete. | The concrete member is casted leaving duct for placing the tendons. One end of the tendon is anchored to the member . After the tendons reaches the desired stress by pulling with it Jack through the duct provided. The other end is also properly anchored to the concrete and the duct is completely filled with cement slurry by grouting. Prestress is his transmitted to concrete. |
3. | Loss of prestress is more. | Loss of prestress is less. |
4. | The cost of pre tensioning system is less. | The cost of post tensioning system is more. |
5. | Pre tensioning is mostly used for small member. | Post tensioning is used for span member. |
6. | Grade of concrete shall not be less than 45 | Grade of concrete shall not be less than 35 |
7. | For ex:- Hoyer system | For ex:-Preyssinet system. |
- |